Rory Johnston, the Toronto oil market researcher behind Commodity Context, ends up holding that the oil shock has become long and messy. Hormuz flows have partly recovered, but inventories are so depleted that high prices last into next year, and the structural surplus he still believes in may not return until about 2028. He argues that China's undisclosed, deliberate import cut, his "Beijing swing", saved the world from much higher prices this summer, and that Chinese diesel exports are the likeliest relief this winter. For Canada, he argues for paying to diversify away from the US until Washington rebuilds a track record.
Why prices stay high. Asked why recovered flows have not lowered prices, Johnston says ex-Iran Middle Eastern crude passed pre-war levels at the end of September, while Saudi Arabia loaded at both coasts, then fell back to about 20% below after Iran's heaviest string of ship attacks of the war. Iranian exports remain offline and refined products are about 50% below pre-war. Transit costs $20–30 a barrel, and Iraq offered $37 a barrel average discounts in September. Brent was about $116 a barrel in extreme backwardation. With the spring's glut drawn down, a smaller deficit worries the market more. He had expected $50 a barrel or lower this year. Now only overfilled commercial tanks, a year or more away, would push prices that low. With up to 10 million barrels a day at political risk, he reads the rising belly of the curve as hedging.
Jawboning. Matt Randolph insists that sanctioned Iranian barrels, about 2 million barrels a day pre-war, still count. He argues that apparent administration market manipulation scared money out early in the war. Johnston agrees jawboning worked: the president's Monday "war is over" posts gapped crude down $10–15 a barrel, because traders expected the war to end that way. Today's $8–10 selloffs bounce back quickly. He expects governments to keep the tool, and calls the trades timed to the posts insider-dealing corruption, not what gave them their force. Asked about American institutions, he calls Trump an idiosyncratic case rather than an institutional collapse.
The Beijing swing. Johnston calls China's import collapse his biggest surprise of the year: about 45% of its pre-war import pace, which he likens to all of Canada's production. He attributes it to China's largest-ever refining-run cut, a halt to stockpiling worth 0.5–1 million barrels a day, and undisclosed reserve draws, which only US energy secretary Chris Wright has mentioned. Apparent diesel demand fell almost 20% while road freight rose 3.5%, which he reads as a stockpile draw. He rejects altruism as the motive. The small answer is protecting price caps: Chinese diesel rose just over 30% while global diesel more than doubled. His preferred answer is preserving export markets in East Asia and Europe, now that real-estate stimulus no longer works. He stresses the data are soft and that respected analysts disagree. A host argues this hands China enormous leverage. Johnston partly agrees, noting the US has few supply tools beyond a low SPR.
Diesel. Johnston traces tightness to 2021–22. COVID closed old Western refineries while new ones abroad were delayed, his "collapsed bridge", and light shale yields little diesel. Russian exports fell from 800,000–900,000 to about 100,000 barrels a day under Ukrainian strikes, but he calls the Iran war the larger loss: 1–1.5 million barrels a day of seaborne diesel. Diesel demand barely responds to price. Putin's pledged 500,000 tons for November is about 125,000 barrels a day. His winter base case repeats 2022, when China raised diesel exports from about 100,000 to 700,000–800,000 barrels a day.
Canada and shipping. Chad Scott raises Johnston's parliamentary testimony that efficiency cost security. Johnston calls the US and Canadian industries one organism, with 95%+ of Canada's exports going south, and calls that concentration natural rather than Ottawa's fault. After the annexation threats and tariffs, Canada is building the costlier 1 million barrel a day Pacific Link line to the BC coast, a deadweight loss that leaves everyone poorer. Middle East–China freight has risen from $2–3 to $20–30 a barrel, and he cites Kpler data showing VLCC utilization below normal, in a market he calls increasingly balkanized.
Debrief. The debrief is brief praise. One host calls Johnston's data the best available.